Skip to main content

Wrongful Death · Settlement · 2022

The guardrail slowed the schedule. So they took it down.

After a 34-year-old ironworker fell from an open deck edge, one email explained why, and a $500,000 offer became a $9.75 million settlement for his family.
Settlement
$9,750,000
Venue
Cameron County
Year
2022

Gross amount, before attorney's fees and case expenses. A fictional result written for this demo.

What happened

He was 34, an ironworker for eleven years and the father of three. That spring he was setting steel on a three-story commercial building going up in Harlingen.

On a Thursday morning he stepped back to guide a bundle of decking and went over the edge of the third-level deck. The fall was 28 feet. He died at the scene.

There had been a cable guardrail along that edge on Monday. By Thursday it was gone. The general contractor's first report said he should have been tied off, and that his own employer was responsible for him.

Their first offer

What they offered. What they paid in the end.

First offer
$500,000
Final settlement, 2022
$9,750,000More than 19 times the first offer

Four months later the general contractor's insurer offered $500,000. Its letter said the company had no duty to protect another company's worker, and that he chose to work near an open edge.

Bars are drawn to scale.

What we did

How the case was built.

An attorney listening to a family at their kitchen table
  1. Found out when the guardrail came down

    His coworkers still had photos on their phones. The time stamps showed the cable up on Monday afternoon and gone by Tuesday morning. It was back in place the day after the fall.

  2. Read the safety plan like a safety analyst

    Before law school, Daniela Treviño wrote safety reports at the port. This site's plan promised a guardrail on every open edge and a written permit before anyone removed one. She asked for the permit. There wasn't one.

  3. Asked for the schedule, then the email

    The project was nineteen days behind, and the contract charged the builder for every day it ran late. In the superintendent's email we found the instruction: pull the east cable so the crane can load faster, and put it back when the deck is done.

  4. Got ready to pick a jury in Brownsville

    Rafael Ortiz spent seven years on the defense side, so he knew how an insurer values a file once an email like that is an exhibit. We prepared the family, the coworkers and an economist for trial. The settlement came eleven days before jury selection.

The outcome

The general contractor and its insurers paid $9.75 million. No amount is the right amount for a husband and a father. This one replaces the paychecks he would have brought home for thirty more years.

A judge approved a separate fund for each of the three children, and their mother kept the house in San Benito. As part of the settlement, the contractor agreed to retrain its superintendents on fall protection.

They kept saying he should have been more careful. Then the lawyers showed them their own email.

His wife, San BenitoA fictional client, written for this demo.

These results are fictional examples created for this demo site. Every case depends on its own facts and law, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Amounts shown are gross recoveries, before attorney's fees and case expenses.

The client, the quote and the facts of this story are fictional. They were written for this demo site and do not describe a real person, company or case.

Free case review

You focus on healing. We'll handle the fight.

Tell us what happened. It takes about two minutes, it's confidential, and it costs nothing. If we can help, we'll get back to you the same day.

No fee unless we win · Se habla español · Confidential