Skip to main content

18-Wheeler & Truck Accidents · Verdict · 2024

The log said he was asleep. The truck said otherwise.

How engine data from a jackknifed 18-wheeler turned a $350,000 offer into a $14.6 million verdict for a family from Pharr.
Jury verdict
$14,600,000
Venue
Hidalgo County
Year
2024

Gross amount, before attorney's fees and case expenses. A fictional result written for this demo.

What happened

A little before seven on a weekday morning, a family of four from Pharr was heading west on I-2 to drop the kids at school and get to work. Ahead of them, an 18-wheeler loaded with produce drifted, overcorrected and folded across three lanes.

Their SUV had nowhere to go. The father, 38, took the worst of it: a brain injury and three fractured vertebrae. His wife broke her pelvis. Their two children, 9 and 6, were bruised and frightened and, thankfully, home by the end of the week.

The driver told the trooper he was rested. His electronic log said the same: ten hours off duty in the sleeper berth the night before.

Their first offer

What they offered. What the jury decided.

First offer
$350,000
Jury verdict, 2024
$14,600,000More than 41 times the first offer

Within the first week, while the father was still in intensive care, the carrier's insurer offered $350,000 to settle every claim for all four of them. It wanted a signature before anyone knew what his care would cost.

Bars are drawn to scale.

What we did

How the case was built.

An attorney holding a client's hand during a hospital visit
  1. Sent the preservation letter the day we were hired

    Isabel Vela put the carrier on written notice within hours: do not repair the truck, do not overwrite the engine computer, do not touch the logs. A court order followed that week.

  2. Read the truck instead of the logbook

    Our reconstruction expert downloaded the engine control module. It showed the truck moving for 15 of the 18 hours before the crash. Federal rules allow 11 hours of driving in a shift. The ten hours of rest in the log never happened.

  3. Followed the edits back to the office

    Daniela Treviño subpoenaed the log's edit history and the dispatcher's messages. The rest period had been entered from the carrier's office after the crash. Two hours before it, dispatch had texted the driver that the load could not be late.

  4. Tried it in Edinburg

    The carrier wanted the case to be about one tired driver. Over nine days of trial, the jury heard from the safety director, the dispatcher and the family. Jurors held the company responsible for the schedule it set.

The outcome

The jury returned a verdict of $14.6 million. It covers the father's medical care for the rest of his life, the income he can no longer earn, and what all four of them went through.

He is home. He is relearning things he used to do without thinking, and his wife is back at work part-time. The children's share sits in accounts a judge approved, waiting for them to turn 18.

They wanted us to sign before my husband could say my name again. Ms. Vela told us to wait until we knew what he was going to need. I'm glad we waited.

Our client, a mother of two from PharrA fictional client, written for this demo.

These results are fictional examples created for this demo site. Every case depends on its own facts and law, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Amounts shown are gross recoveries, before attorney's fees and case expenses.

The client, the quote and the facts of this story are fictional. They were written for this demo site and do not describe a real person, company or case.

Free case review

You focus on healing. We'll handle the fight.

Tell us what happened. It takes about two minutes, it's confidential, and it costs nothing. If we can help, we'll get back to you the same day.

No fee unless we win · Se habla español · Confidential