Skip to main content

Car Accidents · Verdict · 2021

The driver had $30,000 in insurance. The bar had the video.

A nurse driving home from a night shift was hit head-on by a wrong-way drunk driver, and a Hidalgo County jury held the bar that kept serving him responsible too.
Jury verdict
$3,900,000
Venue
Hidalgo County
Year
2021

Gross amount, before attorney's fees and case expenses. A fictional result written for this demo.

What happened

She had just finished a twelve-hour shift in the emergency room and was driving home to Mission on Expressway 83. It was a little after two in the morning.

A pickup came toward her in her own lane. The driver had left a bar in McAllen at closing time and entered the expressway the wrong way, up an exit ramp. They hit nearly head-on.

Her left leg and right wrist were shattered. She had three surgeries in the first year. The driver's blood alcohol tested at more than twice the legal limit, and he carried the minimum insurance Texas allows.

Their first offer

What they offered. What the jury decided.

First offer
$30,000
Jury verdict, 2021
$3,900,000130 times the first offer

The driver's insurer offered his full policy: $30,000, the state minimum. The bar's insurer denied the claim and said he had seemed fine when he left.

Bars are drawn to scale.

What we did

How the case was built.

Isabel Vela at golden hour in McAllen
  1. Sent the bar a preservation letter in the first week

    Bar cameras record over themselves, often within a month. Our letter went out six days after the crash and demanded the video, the receipts and the staff schedule for that night.

  2. Lined up the tab against the video

    His receipt showed eleven drinks in under three hours. The video showed him knock over a stool at 12:40. He was served three more times after that.

  3. Looked where the defense would look

    Rafael Ortiz knew from his defense years that a bar's insurer cares about two things: the video and the training records. Two of the three bartenders working that night had never taken the state's server course.

  4. Tried it in Edinburg

    Isabel Vela tried the case. A toxicologist explained what eleven drinks do to a man his size. The jury found both the driver and the bar responsible.

The outcome

The verdict was $3.9 million. Because the bar was held responsible, there was insurance to pay it. Without the bar in the case, the only money on the table was the driver's $30,000 policy.

She cannot stand through a twelve-hour shift anymore. The verdict paid her medical bills and gave her time to retrain. She works as a nurse case manager now, a few miles from the same emergency room.

I had treated people after crashes like mine. I never knew a bar could be held responsible until Ms. Vela explained it.

Our client, MissionA fictional client, written for this demo.

These results are fictional examples created for this demo site. Every case depends on its own facts and law, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Amounts shown are gross recoveries, before attorney's fees and case expenses.

The client, the quote and the facts of this story are fictional. They were written for this demo site and do not describe a real person, company or case.

Free case review

You focus on healing. We'll handle the fight.

Tell us what happened. It takes about two minutes, it's confidential, and it costs nothing. If we can help, we'll get back to you the same day.

No fee unless we win · Se habla español · Confidential